With reference to centrifugal pumps:
(a) explain why it is common practice to start with the discharge valve closed or throttled;(4)
(b) explain why the delivery valve must not be left closed after starting;(3)
(c) state why it is not always necessary to fit a relief valve.(3)
A centrifugal pump
A centrifugal pump is a type of pump that uses a rotating impeller to increase the pressure and velocity of a fluid. It works on the principle of centrifugal force, where the fluid is accelerated by the impeller and then discharged at a higher pressure and velocity.
1. Centrifugal pumps – Useful Information – Michael-Smith-Engineers.co.uk
2. Centrifugal Pumps: Parts, Types & Working Principle – DXP Enterprises
Key Components:
- Impeller: This is the rotating component of the pump with vanes or blades that impart kinetic energy to the fluid. 1. Impeller – Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org
- Casing: The casing surrounds the impeller and directs the flow of the fluid. It has an inlet (suction) and an outlet (discharge) port. 1. Volute (pump) – Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org2. How does a Centrifugal Pump Work – AROPLUS aroplus.com
- Shaft: Connects the impeller to the motor or other prime mover, transmitting rotational energy to the impeller. 1. Centrifugal pumps – Useful Information – Michael-Smith-Engineers.co.uk www.michael-smith-engineers.co.uk
- Bearings: Support the rotating shaft and reduce friction. 1. What is a Centrifugal Pump? Understanding Its Mechanism, Types, and Applications www.rotechpumps.com
- Seals: Prevent leakage of fluid from the pump casing. 1. Centrifugal Pump: 6 Common Technical Terms and Their Meanings – Sanitary Fittings sanitaryfittings.us
Working Principle:
- Suction: Fluid enters the pump through the suction port and fills the space around the impeller. 1. Centrifugal Pumps | How do they work | Knowledge Hub – Positive Displacement Blowers www.robuschi.com
- Impeller Action: The rotating impeller imparts kinetic energy to the fluid, increasing its velocity. 1. Lesson One – What is a Centrifugal Pump? www.pricepump.com
- Centrifugal Force: Centrifugal force causes the fluid to move radially outward from the center of the impeller. 1. Centrifugal pumps – Useful Information – Michael-Smith-Engineers.co.uk www.michael-smith-engineers.co.uk
- Volute Casing: The fluid enters the volute casing, which is a spiral-shaped chamber that gradually increases in cross-sectional area. This slows down the fluid’s velocity while converting some of its kinetic energy into pressure energy. 1. CENTRIFUGAL PUMP TYPES : – AlfiDelfi alfidelfi.com2. Volute casing – KSB www.ksb.com
- Discharge: The fluid, now at a higher pressure, is discharged from the pump through the discharge port.
Advantages:
- Simple Design: Centrifugal pumps have a relatively simple design with few moving parts, making them easy to manufacture, operate, and maintain. 1. Centrifugal pumps – Useful Information – Michael-Smith-Engineers.co.uk www.michael-smith-engineers.co.uk
- High Flow Rates: They can handle large volumes of fluid, making them suitable for various applications. 1. Centrifugal Pumps| verderliquids.com – Verder Liquids www.verderliquids.com
- Smooth Flow: They produce a continuous, smooth flow of fluid without pulsations. 1. How to Tackle Pulsation Challenges in Pumping – Walchem www.walchem.com
- Handles a Variety of Fluids: Centrifugal pumps can handle various fluids, including water, chemicals, and slurries. 1. Centrifugal Pumps| verderliquids.com – Verder Liquids www.verderliquids.com
Disadvantages:
- Not Self-Priming: Most centrifugal pumps cannot pump air and need to be primed with fluid before they can start pumping. 1. Centrifugal pumps – Useful Information – Michael-Smith-Engineers.co.uk www.michael-smith-engineers.co.uk
- Less Efficient at Low Flows: Their efficiency decreases at low flow rates. 1. Low Flow Concerns in Centrifugal Pumps – A.R. Wilfley & Sons, Inc. www.wilfley.com
- Can be Prone to Cavitation: If the suction pressure drops too low, cavitation (formation of vapor bubbles) can occur, causing damage and noise. 1. What is Pump Cavitation and how to avoid it? – Selwood www.selwood.co.uk
Common Applications:
- Water Supply: Supplying water for domestic, industrial, and agricultural purposes.
- Wastewater Treatment: Pumping and treating sewage and industrial wastewater.
- Marine Applications: Circulating seawater for engine cooling, ballast systems, and firefighting.
- Chemical Processing: Transferring various chemicals in industrial processes. 1. Industrial Applications of Centrifugal Pumps – C&B Equipment, INC. cbeuptime.com
- HVAC Systems: Circulating water or other fluids for heating and cooling systems.
Centrifugal pumps are widely used in various industries and applications due to their simplicity, high flow rates, and ability to handle a wide range of fluids.
Why it is common practice to start with the discharge valve closed
Starting a centrifugal pump with the discharge valve closed or throttled is a common practice for several important reasons:
- Reduces Starting Load on the Motor:
- Minimum Flow Conditions: When the discharge valve is closed or throttled, the pump operates at or near its minimum flow condition. This results in the lowest possible head (pressure) the pump has to overcome. 1. Why Close the Discharge Valve Before Starting the Centrifugal Pump? www.wsv-valve.com
- Lower Starting Torque: The lower head translates to a lower starting torque requirement for the motor. This means the motor needs to draw less current during startup, reducing stress on the electrical system and potentially avoiding motor overheating or tripping circuit breakers. 1. Why Close the Discharge Valve Before Starting the Centrifugal Pump? www.wsv-valve.com
- Prevents Cavitation and Damage:
- NPSH (Net Positive Suction Head): Closing or throttling the discharge valve helps maintain a higher pressure at the pump’s suction side, ensuring adequate NPSH.
- Cavitation Avoidance: Sufficient NPSH prevents cavitation (the formation and collapse of vapor bubbles), which can cause damage to the impeller, reduce pump efficiency, and create noise and vibrations. 1. The Role of NPSH in Preventing Pump Cavitation – Iwaki America Inc. iwakiamerica.com
- Minimizes Water Hammer:
- Controlled Pressure Rise: Starting the pump with a closed or throttled discharge valve allows for a gradual and controlled pressure rise in the system as the valve is slowly opened.
- Water Hammer Prevention: This controlled pressure rise helps prevent water hammer (a sudden pressure surge), which can cause damage to pipes, valves, and other components.
- Facilitates Priming:
- Self-Priming Pumps: Some centrifugal pumps are self-priming, meaning they can pump air to expel it from the system and create a vacuum to draw in fluid. 1. Self-priming centrifugal pumps www.bbapumps.com
- Non-Self-Priming Pumps: For non-self-priming pumps, closing the discharge valve helps create a vacuum on the suction side, aiding in priming the pump and ensuring it’s filled with fluid before starting.
- Operational Flexibility:
- Gradual Flow Control: Starting with the discharge valve closed or throttled allows for gradual control of the flow rate as the valve is slowly opened, preventing sudden surges and potential system upsets.
In summary, starting a centrifugal pump with the discharge valve closed or throttled is a best practice that ensures smooth startup, protects the pump and system from damage, and facilitates priming (if necessary). It’s a crucial step in the safe and efficient operation of centrifugal pumps.
1. Why Should the Outlet Valve be Closed When the Centrifugal Pump is Started?
Why the delivery valve must not be left closed after starting
Leaving the delivery valve closed after starting a centrifugal pump is a critical mistake that can lead to several serious consequences:
- Overheating and Pump Damage:
- Recirculation: With the discharge valve closed, the fluid being pumped has nowhere to go. It recirculates within the pump casing, generating significant heat due to friction.
- Thermal Damage: This excessive heat can damage the pump’s seals, bearings, and even the impeller itself, leading to premature failure and costly repairs.
- Motor Overload and Damage:
- Increased Power Consumption: With the discharge valve closed, the pump operates at its shutoff head, requiring the motor to deliver maximum power.
- Motor Overheating: This prolonged operation at maximum power can cause the motor to overheat and potentially burn out.
- Electrical System Issues: The high current draw can also trip circuit breakers or overload other electrical components.
- System Damage:
- Pressure Buildup: The closed discharge valve leads to a rapid pressure increase within the pump and connected piping.
- Rupture or Leaks: This excessive pressure can cause pipes, valves, or other system components to rupture or develop leaks, resulting in potential flooding, equipment damage, and safety hazards.
- Inefficiency and Energy Waste:
- Zero Flow: With the discharge valve closed, the pump is essentially doing no useful work, yet the motor continues to consume energy.
- Wasted Energy and Costs: This translates to wasted electricity and increased operating costs.
Correct Procedure:
The delivery valve should be opened gradually after the pump has started and reached its normal operating speed. This allows for a controlled pressure rise and ensures the fluid flows through the system as intended.
In summary:
Leaving the delivery valve closed after starting a centrifugal pump is a dangerous practice that can cause significant damage to the pump, motor, and connected system. It’s essential to open the valve as soon as the pump has started to ensure safe and efficient operation.
Why it is not always necessary to fit a relief valve.
While relief valves are critical safety components in many pump systems, it’s not always necessary to fit one on a centrifugal pump, primarily due to its inherent operational characteristics.
1. What does a high-pressure water relief valve do on a water pump? – AWS HYDRO
Key reasons why relief valves might not be needed on centrifugal pumps:
- Self-Limiting Pressure:
- Shutoff Head: Centrifugal pumps have a defined “shutoff head,” which is the maximum pressure they can develop when the discharge valve is completely closed. This pressure is typically within the design limits of the pump and associated piping. 1. Quiz Help: Fundamentals Of Pumps | EZ-pdh.com ez-pdh.com
- Reduced Flow at Higher Pressure: As the discharge pressure increases (due to restrictions in the system or a partially closed valve), the flow rate of a centrifugal pump decreases significantly. This self-limiting behavior reduces the risk of excessive pressure buildup. 1. Pressure Relief Valves: Critical to Pump and System Safety and Reliability www.vikingpump.com2. What does a high-pressure water relief valve do on a water pump? – AWS HYDRO www.aws-hydro.com
- System Design and Protection:
- Other Pressure Relief Mechanisms: The overall system design may incorporate other pressure relief mechanisms, such as:
- System Relief Valves: Installed elsewhere in the system to protect against overpressure from various sources, not just the pump.
- Bypass Lines: Can be used to divert flow back to the suction side or a reservoir if pressure exceeds a certain limit.
- Control Valves: Can be used to regulate flow and pressure in the system, preventing excessive buildup.
- Operational Considerations:
- Unlikely Deadhead Condition: In most applications, centrifugal pumps are not intended to operate with a completely closed discharge valve for extended periods. Operators are generally aware of this and take steps to avoid such situations.
- Monitoring and Control Systems: Modern systems often have monitoring and control systems that detect abnormal pressure conditions and can automatically shut down the pump or take other corrective actions to prevent damage.
- Specific Applications:
- Low-Pressure Systems: In systems with relatively low operating pressures and minimal risk of overpressure, a relief valve might be deemed unnecessary.
- Open Systems: In systems where the discharge is open to the atmosphere or a large reservoir, the risk of overpressure is significantly reduced, making a relief valve less critical.
When Relief Valves Are Necessary:
Despite these factors, there are situations where fitting a relief valve on a centrifugal pump is essential:
- Positive Displacement Pumps: Positive displacement pumps, unlike centrifugal pumps, continue to build pressure even with a closed discharge valve. They almost always require a relief valve.
- High-Pressure Systems: In systems with high operating pressures or where the risk of overpressure is significant (e.g., due to potential blockages or malfunctions), a relief valve is crucial to protect the pump and system components.
- Critical Applications: In critical applications where pump failure could have severe consequences, a relief valve provides an added layer of safety.
In conclusion, while centrifugal pumps often don’t require a dedicated relief valve due to their self-limiting pressure characteristics and system design considerations, it’s important to assess each application carefully. If there’s a potential for overpressure that could damage the pump or system, a relief valve should be installed to ensure safety and prevent costly failures.